Case Study 1: Urban Agriculture

Walking from the pulsing buzz of downtown Vancouver, going South over False Creek I could not think that the view of nature and urban landscape could be more beautiful and integrated. I was wrong. Continuing my walk, along Burrard Street and turning right at West Sixth Avenue, I was surprised with the diversity of plants I found growing there and the burst of colour between the street and a largely abandoned rail track. A closer inspection revealed an array of species and garden designs, as this small strip of land was producing vegetables and flowers for the local residents. This was the real integration of nature in urban. Whether a single tomato plant or a pot of chives sitting alone on a window sill or a balcony, or the rejuvenation of an abandoned lot, city folk have been producing food for the body and soul for perhaps as long as there have been cities. This is urban agriculture. Except for sporadic bursts of interest and activity, for example the essential Victory Gardens during wartime, urban agriculture has gone largely unnoticed and under appreciated and under valued. In recent years there has been a change, and the interest and enthusiasm in this phenomena has been ignited once again.

Urban gardening is not new, and there have always been people teaching gardening and food gardening, but in 1978 there was a gap to be filled in that no one was teaching this kind of gardening from an environmentalist's perspective. Only a handful of people talked about Urban Agriculture in 1978 because urban was consumption, whereas agriculture and farmer were production and rural. It was a challenge to the status quo of the time to have backyard gardens referred to as Urban Agriculture. Urban was "go to the supermarket and buy your food, or go out to a restaurant for dinner." At that time policies were more focused on the large commercial operations, and didn't see agriculture as fitting within the urban context. This situation has improved in recent years, particularly in cities like Vancouver in which there is an active promotion of sustainable initiatives in the city. There was a tacit understanding that farmers were the people who actually knew what plants were and how to grow them, even though in the centre of cities people have always grown food on some scale. As society became more affluent through the 50s and 60s, there was a tendency to move away from such activity. Distant in the past were the urban "Victory Gardens" promoted as a civil effort during World War II, as a vital part of the food supply supply in war torn Europe and throughout North America. After the war the food gardens were increasingly replaced with a monoculture grass species, until the urban food garden became a distant memory.

You can find proof of this enthusiasm if you continue along W. Sixth Ave for two blocks and turn left at the Alpine Garden on the corner of Sixth and Maple Street. There you will find a group of dedicated individuals working quietly to educate the public as to the possibilities of urban farming. One day in mid-June (2003) I went visiting to learn more about this group and their activities. The organization is “City Farmer, Canada’s Office of Urban Agriculture.” Road Sign
(Note, click on images to enlarge.)
Mike and Sharon
Mike and Sharon
I was met by Michael Leventon, Executive Director, and later Sharon Gillard, Head Gardener. We spent the afternoon chatting about the history of the organization and its current activities, and then walked around the garden. What follows is my account; any errors or omissions are those of the author, not that of City Farmer. The following is their story and the story of the garden as they shared it on that afternoon.

 

The Society was celebrating its 25th year as a non-profit society and charitable group, promoting urban agriculture primarily, but also associated with conservation and environmental issues, and the use of appropriate technologies. Mike defined their raison d'etre as: "We are urban and we are into green things, food, healthy non-chemical lawns, turning organic wastes into compost for application to the soil for food production in the city, water conservation, and an array of other environmental issues."

The origins of City Farmer were in the post-energy crisis of the 70s and it started as an energy conservation initiative. Food was the issue they chose as a means to reduce energy consumption. For the urban dweller, to have food produced closer to their door (that is within the city) is the most direct way to reduce energy use. "The Society basically was a go down the back lane and look at home gardens, and say we want to know how they're growing this food, and how much they're growing. And really to let other city people know who might have only lawns and vacant lots that there is something different, maybe more productive, more conserver oriented that they can do with their time."

City Farmer is a catch name, that while meaning the same thing as urban agriculture, also says that you can do something different as a city person and have fun with it. Since it was founded in 1978 the society has basically been about water, waste, and food. Their work can be reduced to plant, soil and sunlight, and then the "trimmings" can be tacked on. Those trimmings, or issues, can be quite fashionable, and do change with the times. The energy crisis that was so front and centre in the 1970s has given way to issues such as organic waste diversion, water conservation, pesticide free cities, and organic food production within the city, among others. City Farmer is in a fortunate position for many reasons, but a very important one is that it is supported, in part, by the City of Vancouver. The City is very green, and for example, with a mandate is to reduce costs composting is part of its solid waste management. The City therefore is a supporter of City Farmer's compost hotline. The compost hotline has been operating since 1990 and serves the whole lower mainland. The staff respond to over 5000 calls per year on a range of questions. The questions can be very basic, such as "Where do I get a bin?" to I have flies or a rodent, what do I do?" In addition, there are backyard demonstrations at the garden, and the staff are in demand to give talks. Composting, an activity that was shunned not so long ago, is a very hot topic and people are genuinely interested in composting their organic wastes.

The Society believes in responding to the needs of the public rather than pushing their agenda, but they are also very proactive. Outreach is a very important activity for responding to people's interests and for creating an awareness of alternatives. Also, outreach combined with demonstration is a way to have something for the public to come and look at and to experience the potential. The public will ask questions, and sometimes the topic is new, so it has to be researched. For example, two current issues are the West Nile Virus and pesticide free lawns. The West Nile Virus has resulted in screening being placed on the water collection tanks or the addition of an insecticidal soap to the holding tank. The lawn issue is really becoming important as municipalities are moving toward banning pesticides within the city. The City itself is a lot greener, and is advocating green practices. The Society is responding with workshops and demonstrations on low input, pesticide free landscapes.

Promoting local initiatives is also important for the Society, and so a contest for the Best Food Gardener in Vancouver was held in 2000. The entrants were from across the city, and were nominated by friends and relatives. It was a wonderful learning experience, as they came to experience the tremendous knowledge and expertise that existed within the city, some of which has been passed down through the generations. The three first place winners were elderly gentleman, all over the age of 70, of Mediterranean origin. One of the many exciting experiences was the discovery of a tomato that had been carefully selected over many years by one of the gardeners. It had a large tomato at the end of the truss and others were a smaller paste type and it just burst with flavour. This tomato may be available in the future as Rocco's Favourite. An important discovery was the value of the experience that exists among the many varied gardeners of the city. For example, knowledge of what works in the local region, seeds selected and collected over years, thus assuring a plant selection that is going to be most suited to the peculiarities of the city environment are a few of thediscoveries. While the knowledge is there, it is not so present in the younger generations of today, and there is a deepening disconnect with the food production chain. According to Mike and his team, preserving and disseminating this information to as wide a population as possible is an important part of the what City Farmer is about.

A need is emerging in that not only is the knowledge of how to grow food being lost, but also that of how to prepare the food being produced. Therefore, talk of urban agriculture, that is food production within the city, needs to be complimented with discussions on how to prepare food. The group has identified that there is a need to expand the reach from "garden to plate." Based on this need a very important part of outreach and education is the use of the internet. For these reasons City Farmer has been on-line since 1994. For Mike the evolution of the internet since that time has been very exciting, and it is astonishing the kinds of connections that can go on. At the local level outreach is mainly focused on activities centred around the garden and on telephone consultations, whereas at the global level outreach is via the internet web of connections. The internet has speeded up and expanded the reach, the interactions and the sharing of information globally.

The 25 years plus with City Farmer has given Mike a very unique perspective on society. He has a belief that through education, society can move in a very green way over time. His organization is contributing to this by having the answers to many of the problems that are current in peoples minds. He feels that most people respond with, "What can I do?" rather than "The sky is falling." The society is constantly looking for things that people can do in a practical workable way and make them feel that they have a positive effect.


The Garden  


The garden was started in 1981 in order to have something tangible to demonstrate to people that you don't need pesticides to produce food. In 1981 there was little in the way of public education, formally or informally, so they too began with an outreach program, initially as a series of lectures to educate the public on the topic of urban agriculture. City Farmer is still doing this, and I think in today's world the need is still as acute as it was in 1981.

(Read: Harrowsmith Article, 1984)

Herb Bed
Sharon's Herb Bed

The gardening season begins the third Saturday of February with "Seedy Saturday." The event is held across the country but on different dates, depending on the arrival of spring. Therefore event begins in Vancouver each year. The next big event is an organic gardening course that is 2-hours sessions held each Saturday during March. Most of the people that come have no idea how to plant a seed, as there is a real disconnect with where food comes from. The basics of organic is the same whether in the country or the city, but there are specific peculiarities and challenges to growing in the city. There are space limitations, problems with soil contamination, and shade from buildings and trees. The program focuses on addressing those challenges and making gardening doable for the very beginner or for someone with limited space. So they start with something very easy like what kind of plants people like to grow, and then measure the actual space available and design the garden. At the end of the course the participants are encouraged to continue visiting the garden throughout the season.

According to Sharon one of the challenges that an urban gardener faces is how to practice crop rotation when quite often there is no space available for this, or when there is a permanent trellis that cannot be moved. The solution is to move the soil. The space challenge poses another problem in limiting the type and volume of production, so wherever possible go vertical (e.g. pole beans instead of bush beans).

The Society promotes both through lectures and most importantly through demonstrations on-site in the garden, diversity in plant species, and the generous use of compost. They provide such tips as when building a compost pile, people often forget to collect the browns, so there is a need to have a stock on hand. This can be accomplished simply by collecting the leaves in the fall, and what is not used in the compost will make an excellent mulch. As in the country, the city can have wildlife problems, not bear and deer, but rather raccoons, the eastern grey squirrel, crows, skunks and domestic pets. The savvy urban farmer needs to know how to deal with them, another important issue that is addressed.

The staff have learned that people have a fear and strong dislike for insects, which can be a problem for the beneficial insects in the garden. There is a whole education program on the use of beneficial insects and the importance of plant diversity to attract them to the garden. Particularly important is education with children, so they can learn which insects are beneficial and therefore not develop a fear of them.

In addition to the educational value of the garden for urban farming it also serves to increase general awareness of nature. Too, it has served as an excellent "classroom" for ESL classes. Plants and the related discussions on food really get people talking, and they practice the language in a very relaxed way.

I had noticed in Vancouver that in the middle of streets or jutting out from curb, are wonderful little gardens. I learnt from Sharon what those are called, - "Traffic Calming Bulges." What a delightful name! They can be adopted by an individual or a neighbourhood and are used to grow plants. This is supported by the city and the city will provide a plant budget. Part of Sharon's outreach work is to talk to the public about those bulge gardens, and to provide tips for managing them in a workable and doable alternative way that fits within the city guidelines.

If you are in Vancouver, you are invited to visit the garden and to experience this wonderful example of urban farming and appropriate use of technology first hand.

 

Images from the Garden

 
 


Other projects


The Society is actively involved in many projects related to improving the urban environment, and creating a more ecological friendly living space. Below is a short overview of some the important projects that are currently on-going.


 
Natural Lawn Care

As more and more municipalities are moving to ban pesticides the requests for information on alternative lawn care is increasing. Along the curb in front of the building there is a wonderful demonstration on the use of native plants, water-wise lawn care, and mulch mowing.

Click here for information on this program.

 

 

 

Country Lane

The country lane leading to the garden from the side is the second of three demonstration lanes that the city is evaluating as an alternative to a totally paved lane or an unpaved gravel one. Everything is permeable, so as to allow as much water to enter the soil as possible. The area for traffic is made of a plastic grid material called “Golpla,” and with this particular lane the area for the tire tracks is filled with gravel. The remaining part of the gird structure comes pre-planted with grass. The material is quite durable and can handle large vehicles like those used for recycle pick-up.

Click here for more information on this project.
[Click for more information on Golpla]

 

 

 
Cob Shed and Cob Oven

The tool shed was needing to be replaced, so an alternative construction, "cob construction," is also being demonstrated while creating a a very esthetically pleasing addition to the landscape. As well, a cob oven has been constructed to serve in demonstrating some food preparation techniques. The shed itself will have a “living” roof.

Click here for more information on the Cob Shed and Oven, and to see images of the finished project.

 

Cob Construction Cob Construction Cob Construction

 
The Compost Toilet

I was fascinated to find a compost toilet in one corner of the garden. It too is the subject of lots of questions, especially from little boys. Equally there is a great interest on the part of foreign visitors, particularly from Asian countries like Japan and Korea. The building was constructed out of recycled utility poles that were destined for the landfill. The toilet is very functional, and has no odour problems. The compost from the toilet is used on the ornamentals.

Click here for more information.

 

Compost Toilet Compost Toilet Compost Toilet
 

 
Water Wise Project

The City of Vancouver has a program designed to reduce the consumption of domestic water and to reduce the amount of rainwater that is entering the city's sewer. Water conservation is important in the city because, despite its reputation, Vancouver can have extended dry periods. The other part of the program is to reduce the amount of rain water entering the drainage system, as the storm drains and the domestic sewers are still for the most part connected. During periods of heavy rain the system can become overloaded.

Click here for more information.

 

Water Wise Water Wise Water Wise
 

 
Urban Composting

In addition to operating the Compost Hotline, along the garden fence there are several demonstrations on the use of backyard composting and a vermiculture, or worm composting, demonstration on the other side. Worm composting demonstrations are popular at schools, and the kits are promoted for apartment composting. Demonstrations and talks are given on compost making and use, both on-site and at various outreach events.

Click here for more information on vermiculture.
Click here for more information on composting.

 

Compost Compost Compost Worm bin
 

 

Outreach Signage and Information Dissemination

Providing information to the public is very important for City Farmer. Below is a sampling of the printed materials that visitors to the garden can take away and the educational posters that explain the processes and procedures for the on-site demonstrations.

 

Office Sinage Sign
Sinage Sinage Sign
Sinage Sinage Water Wise
 
Top

© 2003 by Norman Goodyear
Last Updated: July 19, 2007